Coventry's Primitives are one of best
results of a British pop genre that first gained notoriety around
1986, in the wake of the Jesus and Mary Chain (but with a backwards
nod to early Blondie). Characterized by self-consciously naive
vocals and distorto-guitar backing tracks that pay tribute to
the '60s while reveling in post-punk insouciance, such efforts
can either be utterly charming or noxiously grating. Thanks
to excellent songwriting and the enchanting vocals of Tracy
Tracy (guitarist/songwriter Paul Court sings the occasional
tune as well), the Primitives have made some sparkling catchy
bubblegum gems. Unfortunately, the young quartet peaked early
and has been sagging downhill ever since.
The most memorable tracks on the wonderful
Lovely reprise material from the group's early UK singles. (The
American edition was reissued with the post-LP "Way Behind
Me," also included on Pure). Produced by Paul Sampson (a
veteran, with Paul King, of the Reluctant Stereotypes, who later
became the Primitives' bassist), Lovely runs through a variety
of musical formats--from abject California bubblegum pop ("Thru
the Flowers," the ultimate "Crash," "Stop
Killing Me") to early Blondiepunk ("Nothing Left")
and '60's mock-Indian psychedelia ("Shadow"). An ingenious
and tune-crazy album of instantly accessible pop standards.
The two inter-album EPs contain some
interesting non-LP material. The Out of Reach 12-inch plucks
four songs from Lovely and adds live takes of "Crash"
and "Really Stupid." Secrets, a two-song preview of
Pure, adds the song's demo and a non-LP bonus.
Pure has its charms, but this attempt
to fancy things up in the face of inconsistent material leaves
it no match for the first LP. Bookended by the rushing "Secrets"
and the gently swaying "Summer Rain," fine songs like
"Outside," "Lonely Streets" and the spectacular
"Way Behind Me" all unearth delightful new ingredients
with which to modulate the group's stylistic approach. Amusing
little guitar references to the Who, Status Quo and Sonny and
Cher add to the fun. But other songs are half-baked or dull,
pale rewrites of prior tunes. Slathering echo on the vocals
in an obvious homage to the J&M Chain ("All the Way
Down") is a bad idea, as is the mild infusion of Manchester
house rhythm in the clunky "Sick of It." (The British
album has two songs not on the American; the British CD further
adds an alternate version of "All the Way Down" and
"I Almost Touched You" from the Secrets EP.)
Compiling the Primitives' first four
releases, 86-88 includes the miserably primitive Thru the Flowers
debut EP and the title track's vastly superior remake, two additional
three-song singles ("Really Stupid" and "Stop
Killing Me," both with neat non-LP tunes) and a rare alternate
version of "Shadow" from a limited-edition give-away
45.
Altricia Gethers, Ira Robbins www.trouserpress.com